Sony defeats £2 billion UK lawsuit over PlayStation Store prices
The Competition Appeal Tribunal ruled that the claim failed to show Sony broke competition law, so UK PlayStation owners will not receive compensation.
By GlobalTidingsPublished 3 min read
Sony has defeated a class action worth almost £2 billion that accused it of overcharging millions of UK PlayStation players for digital games and add-on content.
London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claim in its entirety on Tuesday, 17 November, after a trial that began in March. In a unanimous judgment, the three-member panel chaired by Ben Tidswell said the class representative had failed to establish that Sony infringed competition law.
What the claim said
The case was brought in 2022 by consumer campaigner Alex Neill on behalf of about 12.2 million people in the UK. It argued that Sony abused a dominant position because digital games and in-game content for PlayStation consoles can only be bought through Sony’s own PlayStation Store.
The claim said the 30% commission Sony takes on digital sales pushed prices up, and that players paid around 20% more than they would have in a competitive market. It sought about £1.49 billion in damages, rising to almost £1.97 billion with interest. Claimants’ lawyers told the tribunal that Sony could set retail prices for digital content without facing any competition from other stores.
Why the tribunal disagreed
The tribunal did not accept that buying a PlayStation locks players into a separate market. It found that Sony competes in a wider market for gaming systems that includes Xbox, Nintendo and PC, and that people can still buy physical games instead of downloads.
It also found that Sony had no legal duty under competition law to let rival stores sell digital content on its consoles, and it rejected the argument that Sony’s margins on digital games and add-ons were excessive or unfair.
What it means for players
Nothing changes at the checkout. PlayStation Store prices stay as they are, and there is no payout for UK gamers. Estimates before the ruling had suggested each eligible player might have received around £162 if the claim had succeeded.
The wider picture
The case was one of several large collective actions against technology platforms in the UK. Last year the same tribunal ruled against Apple over its App Store commissions, a decision Apple is appealing, and a claim against Google is due to go to trial. Sony’s win suggests that the outcome in each case depends heavily on how the market is defined, and that games consoles, which compete with each other and with physical sales, may be judged differently from smartphone app stores.
Sources
Written by GlobalTidings from the reporting and documents listed above. See our editorial standards.