Personal loan or credit line: which costs less?
A loan gives you one sum and a fixed end date. A credit line lets you borrow, repay and borrow again. The cheaper one depends on how you will use it.
By GlobalTidingsUpdated 2 min read
In short
- A personal loan suits a single cost you know in advance.
- A credit line suits costs that arrive unevenly or that you cannot size yet.
- Compare the APR with fees included, and the total you would repay.
How a personal loan works
You borrow a fixed amount and repay it in equal monthly payments over a fixed term, usually at a fixed rate. You know the end date and the total cost on the day you sign. Some lenders charge an arrangement fee, and some charge for early repayment.
How a credit line works
A line of credit gives you a limit. You draw what you need, pay interest only on what you have drawn, and can borrow again as you repay. Overdrafts work this way, and so do home equity lines, which are secured on your property. Rates are usually variable. Minimum payments can be low, which is convenient but can keep the debt alive for years.
A worked comparison
Borrow 10,000 at 9% as a three-year loan and the payment is about 318 a month. You pay about 1,448 in interest and the debt is gone after 36 payments.
Draw the same 10,000 from a credit line at 9% and pay only the interest, about 75 a month. After three years you have paid about 2,700 and still owe the full 10,000. The credit line is cheaper only if you repay it faster than the loan would have required.
Which one fits
- Choose a loan for one known cost, such as a car or a single repair bill, or when you want a fixed end date.
- Choose a credit line for staged or uncertain costs, such as building work paid in phases, and when you are confident you will pay it down quickly.
Before you sign either
- APR: the yearly cost with fees included. Compare this figure, not the headline rate.
- Fixed or variable: a variable rate can rise during the term.
- Secured or unsecured: if the borrowing is secured on your home, the home is at risk if you fall behind.
- Fees: arrangement, annual, drawdown and early repayment charges.
- Total repayable: the figure that shows what the borrowing really costs.
This guide is general information, not financial advice. Rates, rules and tax treatment differ between countries and change over time. Check the current terms with the provider and consider speaking to a qualified adviser.